Autochthonous dengue in mainland France, 2022: geographical expansion and increase in incidence

Dengue autochtone en France métropolitaine, 2022 : extension géographique et augmentation de l’incidence

Publié le 21 mars 2023

Arboviruses such as dengue viruses (DENV), chikungunya virus (CHIKV) or Zika virus (ZIKV) present a risk in an increasing number of regions. This is due to an expansion of the vector Aedes albopictus, commonly known as the tiger mosquito.

In France, a surveillance system for these arboviruses (see box) exists since 2006. It identifies cases imported from areas where these viruses circulate in order to limit autochthonous transmissions on the French territory. In metropolitan France, since the first identification of an autochthonous case in 2010, transmissions on the national territory tend to increase each year. 

In 2022, the dengue situation in metropolitan France appears exceptional in terms of both the number of transmission events and the number of autochthonous cases. By the end of October 2022, the surveillance system had identified 65 autochthonous cases of dengue fever corresponding to nine outbreaks, against 48 cases identified over the last 10 years. No other European country experienced such a situation; France was the only one to report autochthonous cases this year. 

The article recently published in Eurosurveillance1 focuses on this exceptional spread of dengue on the French territory.     

3 questions for Amandine Cochet, Occitania Regional Office, and Clémentine Calba, Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur Regional Office, Santé publique France.

Clémentine Calba

How was the situation observed in 2022 exceptional compared to previous years and other European countries?

Considering the progression of Ae. albopictus colonisation, autochthonous outbreaks of viruses transmitted by this vector are now expected every year in the South of France.

However, in 2022, the situation regarding the dengue virus in metropolitan France was exceptional both in terms of number of transmission events and number of cases. From the time the surveillance system was set up in 2006 up to the start of the 2022 season, 19 events of autochthonous transmissions had been identified in metropolitan France with a total of 48 cases. This number of cases was exceeded during the 2022 season alone, which counted a total of 65 autochthonous cases from nine transmission events. Furthermore, an increase in the intensity of transmission events was observed for 2022, which included the greatest dengue outbreak ever documented in Europe. This outbreak, responsible for 34 cases from a single transmission chain, concerned two municipalities in the French department of Alpes-Maritimes. Another striking aspect of the 2022 season was the apparition of autochthonous transmission events in departments that were previously untouched by dengue. This was the case in western Occitania: outbreaks of autochthonous cases were identified in the Pyrénées-Orientales, the Hautes-Pyrénées, Tarn-et-Garonne and Haute-Garonne. Previously, only Gard and Hérault – situated in the east of the region and colonised by the tiger mosquito for longer – were affected. A first autochthonous transmission event was also described in Corse-du-Sud. 

This year appears particularly exceptional because France is the only European country to have declared autochthonous dengue cases.

Is there a hypothesis, notably related to environmental conditions, which could explain France’s exceptionally high number of autochtonous cases for this year? Do we have the capacity to characterise the climatic, socio-economic and environmental determinants that favour transmission?

There are multiple determinants of arbovirus transmission. They are mainly influenced by interactions between vector populations, virus strains and the global environment.

An autochtonous transmission cycle starts with an introduction of the virus to the metropolitan territory via persons infected during a trip to a zone where the virus circulates. International trips, in the current context of globalisation, are therefore a factor to consider in the apparition of autochtonous transmission events. However, the risk is not directly correlated to the number of imported cases: from May to November 2022, 255 imported dengue cases were identified, around three times less than in 2019 (657 cases) and 2020 (834 cases)*. An important determinant is the compatibility of the vector/pathogen pair: some viral strains are more adapted to the metropolitan vector and the introduction of a single imported case can be at the origin of a local transmission chain.

Finally, environmental conditions have a major impact on the geographical distribution of vectors, their density and activity, as well as on the multiplication and transmission of pathogens. Temperature, rainfall and land use will thus influence the efficiency of the vector system, i.e., the capacity to ensure efficient circulation of the virus. The spring and summer of 2022 were particularly warm, which may have affected the vectors’ activity and the efficiency of dengue virus transmission. 

Further research remains necessary to better characterise the determinants (climate, socio-economic, environmental) of local transmission events and their extension. 

*164 dengue cases were imported to metropolitan France in 2021.

How might this situation affect our ability to identify cases through surveillance systems such as the one set up in France? What actions should be planned to ensure its sustainability?

The surveillance system set up in metropolitan France is very sensible and unique at European level; it allows the reactive deployment of mosquito control measures around cases (see box). However, it requires considerable human and material resources, especially when the importation pressure is strong or when the system is confronted by numerous autochthonous transmission events, like in 2022. 

This year certainly represents the beginning of what lies ahead in a context of the vector's continuous expansion, which in turn increases risk on the territory. On 1 January 2022, 67 metropolitan departments were considered colonised by the Aedes albopictus vector (34 in 2016). Due to the limited resources allocated to the surveillance and management of these health threats, we must reflect on how to adapt the system to anticipate the multiplication of autochthonous transmission episodes. This will probably involve prioritising surveys, whether entomological or epidemiological. 
Health professionals, like travellers, play an essential role in the prevention of arboviruses in metropolitan France. Public awareness and the involvement of local authorities remain key weapons in the fight against vector populations in order to reduce their density and the associated health risks.

To ensure a viable surveillance scheme, the implication of its main actors must be maintained by consolidating the biology laboratory network and by raising awareness, both among patients about seeking medical consultation in case of symptoms and among health professionals about diagnosing these arboviruses. 

[1] Cochet Amandine, Calba Clémentine, Jourdain Frédéric, Grard Gilda, Durand Guillaume André, Guinard Anne, Investigation team, Noël Harold, Paty Marie-Claire, Franke Florian. Autochthonous dengue in mainland France, 2022: geographical extension and incidence increase. Euro Surveill. 2022;27(44):pii=2200818. https:// doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2022.27.44.2200818 

Surveillance of arboviruses in France

Due to the presence of the Aedes albopictus vector in metropolitan France, dengue, chikungunya and Zika have been monitored by a surveillance system since 2006. Throughout the year, these arboviruses are subject to mandatory reporting: health professionals must report all biologically documented cases to the Regional Health Agencies (ARS: Agence régionale de santé).

The surveillance system is each year reinforced, from May to November, during the estimated activity period of Ae. albopictus. Awareness campaigns to inform health professionals, doctors and laboratories aout the arbovirus transmission risk and case reporting are launched at the beginning of the season.

Furthermore, an automated system for transferring results from the Eurofins Biomnis and Cerba laboratories makes it possible to identify cases that have not been reported. Each identified case triggers an epidemiological investigation by the ARS, as well as a prompt intervention by vector control services (LAV: services de lutte antivectorielle) around potentially viremic cases, to avoid local transmission of the virus. A case is considered autochthonous when a person who has not travelled for 15 days before the apparition of clinical signs was contaminated by a local mosquito, itself infected from stinging a viremic person who has returned from a trip in an endemic area. 

The National Reference Center (CNR: Centre national de référence) for arboviruses is responsible for the biological confirmation of the first autochthonous cases during a local transmission event. When an autochthonous case is identified, an active search for cases is immediately initiated in the area surrounding the case to determine the extent of the local transmission: door-to-door surveys in a 150-250 m radius, communications with health professionals and a press release to raise awareness within the general population. Every situation of autochthonous transmission is the subject of a risk assessment regarding the safety of health products of human origin.