Impact of smoking reduction scenarios on the burden of myocardial infarction in the French population by 2035

Impact of tobacco prevention scenarios on the burden of myocardial infarction in France in 2035.

Cardiovascular disease is a major global health burden. In France, these diseases account for over one million hospital admissions each year and are the second leading cause of death after cancer. A previous study by Santé publique France (1) predicted an increase in the prevalence of myocardial infarction in France between 2015 and 2035, with cases doubling among both men and women. This increase is partly due to the inevitable aging of the population.

Smoking is one of the main cardiovascular risk factors. In France, it is estimated that 21% of cardiovascular hospitalizations can be attributed to smoking.

The proportion of daily smokers remains high in France, standing at 24.5% in 2022 (2).

The first National Tobacco Control Program (PNLT) for the period 2014–2019 led to a gradual increase in the price of tobacco, the introduction of plain packaging for cigarettes, the reimbursement of nicotine replacement therapies, and the annual “No Tobacco Month” public health campaign run by Santé publique France. The overall success of this smoking reduction program was the subject of a recent assessment by the OECD, conducted in partnership with Santé publique France (see Box – Assessment of tobacco control policy).

The third PNLT, launched in November 2023, has set a quantitative objective of reducing smoking to less than 20% of daily smokers in the population by 2027.

As the 9th “No Tobacco Month” begins (see Box – No Tobacco Month: the health and economic impact), a study by Santé publique France carried out in partnership with the University of Bordeaux School of Public Health (ISPED) has just been published in the journal Clinical Epidemiology, which emphasizes that ambitious quantitative smoking reduction objectives are needed to reduce the burden of myocardial infarction.

3 questions for Johann Kuhn and Valérie Olié*, Santé

Portrait de J.Khun et V.Olie

*This work was carried out as part of a thesis co-supervised by Yann Le Strat, Pierre Joly, Christophe Bonaldi (Data Analysis, Processing, and Support Department), and Valérie Olié (Noncommunicable Diseases and Trauma Department), Santé publique France.

Myocardial infarction is a major public health burden in France: it is one of the main cardiovascular diseases, which together account for the second leading cause of death in France. Myocardial infarction accounts for more than 70,000 hospitalizations per year in France. Tobacco is one of the main risk factors for this disease, and what distinguishes the cardiovascular impact in smokers is that it is immediate, whereas cancers may take several years of exposure to develop. In addition, cardiovascular risk is reduced as soon as the individual stops smoking. These two factors make myocardial infarction a good model for studying the impact of smoking reduction scenarios in France.

In this study, we modeled four smoking reduction scenarios based on the proportion of smokers aged 18–75 in the French population between 2024 and 2035. The first scenario, known as the baseline scenario, uses the current trend of smoking reduction in France, which is a 1% annual decline in the proportion of smokers. The second scenario simulates a reduction in smokers twice the current rate, i.e., 2% per year. The third scenario applies one of the preliminary objectives of the National Tobacco Control Plan (PNLT), which aims for 22% of the population to be smokers by 2027, equating to a 10% reduction per year. Finally, the fourth scenario simulates a complete cessation of tobacco use starting in 2024, i.e., the proportion of smokers being 0% from that year onward. The data supporting these different scenarios are drawn from the French National Health Data System (SNDS), the 2021 Santé publique France Health Barometer, and INSEE.

Implementing scenario 3 would mean that 45,000 myocardial infarctions could be prevented by 2035, more than 60% of which would be in the under-65 age group, as well as 4,500 deaths due to myocardial infarction and 265,000 deaths from all causes. The second scenario, which is less ambitious in terms of reducing smoking prevalence, would yield significant gains compared to maintaining the current trend, but the impact would be smaller than in scenario 3: 6,800 fewer myocardial infarctions, 640 fewer deaths from myocardial infarction, and 40,000 fewer deaths from all causes.

Finally, a theoretical scenario of complete cessation of smoking in France by 2024, used to estimate the maximum benefit, would mean that 103,000 myocardial infarctions, 12,800 deaths from myocardial infarction, and 653,000 deaths from all causes could be prevented by 2035. Beyond the impact on the number of cases and deaths, a reduction in the prevalence of smoking in the population would result in the average age of disease onset being delayed by between 2.8 and 4.1 years in men and between 1.1 and 2.0 years in women. These results confirm the relevance of ambitious quantitative targets for reducing smoking.

Our research has shown that, without any preventive measures, the prevalence of myocardial infarction in France will increase significantly by 2035. This projected increase is linked to several factors, both demographic—due to the inevitable aging of the population—and epidemiological, as the prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors remains high in France.

It is estimated that nearly half of the increase in the prevalence of myocardial infarction by 2035 is attributable to population aging alone. INSEE data show that by 2050 in France, people aged 60 and older will account for one-third of the population, compared to one-fifth in 2005.

Prevention takes on major importance in this context, as it does for chronic diseases more broadly. The risk factors responsible for the highest proportion of cardiovascular events are smoking, high cholesterol, diabetes, and hypertension. These four risk factors can be modified through behavioral changes. While smoking is currently the focus of active and regular prevention campaigns that have proven effective, the other three risk factors remain at very high levels in the population (30% of adults have hypertension, 7.4% of adults have diabetes, and 23.3% of adults have high LDL cholesterol), and a significant proportion of people have not been screened (45% for hypertension, 23% for diabetes, and 43% for high LDL cholesterol) (3–5). Improving screening for hypertension, diabetes, and hypercholesterolemia, as well as running nutrition campaigns, are of greater priority than ever if we are to reverse these trends.

The multiple-state model used for myocardial infarction can be applied to other cardiovascular or chronic diseases, provided that appropriate hypotheses are formulated for each targeted disease.

Applying the model to all tobacco-related diseases would quantify the overall benefit that could be expected from smoking prevention.

It is also possible to consider using these models for other risk factors or combining several risk factors. However, we must bear in mind that these models are complex and require the formulation of many hypotheses to function effectively. They are also very computationally intensive.

In addition to simulating prevention scenarios, the advantage of these models is that they demonstrate the significant impact of aging on the prevalence of cardiovascular diseases by incorporating INSEE’s population age structure projections into the modeling. Given the significant influence of demographics on the projected prevalence trend, our results highlight the need to adapt the healthcare system to anticipate treating rising patient numbers. These adaptations would be required not only during the acute hospital admission phase, but also in the management of the chronic phase. This includes cardiac rehabilitation followed by the provision of secondary and tertiary prevention and therapeutic patient education upon discharge.

Beyond cardiovascular diseases, population aging has an impact on all age-related chronic diseases. Our findings regarding the need for more active prevention and adaptation of the healthcare system apply to all chronic diseases.

Kuhn J, Olié V, Grave C, Le Strat Y, Bonaldi C, Joly P. Impact of Smoking Reduction Scenarios on the Burden of Myocardial Infarction in the French Population Until 2035. Clin Epidemiol. 2024 Sep 7;16:605-616. doi: 10.2147/CLEP.S440815.

Also cited in this article:

(1) Kuhn J, Olié V, Grave C, Le Strat Y, Bonaldi C, Joly P. Estimating the future burden of myocardial infarction in France until 2035: an illness-death model-based approach. CLEP. 2022;14:255–264. doi:10.2147/CLEP.S340031.

(2) Pasquereau A, Andler R, Guignard R, Soullier N, Beck F, Nguyen-Thanh V. Prevalence of smoking and vaping in mainland France in 2022 among 18- to 75-year-olds. Bull Épidémiol Hebd. 2023;(9-10):152-8. http://beh.santepubliquefrance.fr/beh/2023/9-10/2023_9-10_1.html

(3) Perrine AL, Lecoffre C, Blacher J, Olié V. Hypertension in France: prevalence, treatment, and control in 2015 and trends since 2006. Weekly Epidemiological Bulletin 2017;10:170-9.

(4) Lailler G, Piffaretti C, Fuentes S, Nabe HD, Oleko A, Cosson E, et al. Prevalence of prediabetes and undiagnosed type 2 diabetes in France: Results from the national ESTEBAN survey, 2014–2016. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2020;165:108252.

(5) Blacher J, Gabet A, Vallee A, Ferrieres J, Bruckert E, Farnier M, et al. Prevalence and management of hypercholesterolemia in France, the Esteban observational study. Medicine (Baltimore) 2020;99:e23445.

Assessment of the tobacco control policy

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and Santé publique France collaborated to assess the health and economic impact of the tobacco control policy implemented in France between 2016 and 2020. This analysis was recently published in the journal Tobacco Control.

The analysis projected results through 2050 using the OECD microsimulation model for strategic public health planning for non-communicable diseases (OECD SPHeP-NCD). The model’s parameters integrate data on behavioral risk factors—such as smoking—along with demographic and population health data from national sources (including the Santé publique France Health Barometer) and international databases. In the model, each individual faces various risks of illness, which may or may not be smoking-related, depending on their profile. The costs of treating diseases are estimated based on an annual cost per case. Additionally, the impact of these diseases on the labor market is assessed.

Significant health and economic gains

Over the period 2023–2050, the measures implemented between 2016 and 2020 (including a gradual increase in the price of tobacco, the introduction of plain packaging for cigarettes, the annual “No Tobacco Month” campaign, and the standard reimbursement of nicotine replacement therapies) would result in:

  • Approximately 4 million cases of chronic diseases prevented (1.87 million cases of musculoskeletal disorders, 1.54 million cases of lower respiratory tract infections, 275,000 cases of COPD, 170,000 cases of cancer, 104,000 cases of cardiovascular disease, 40,000 cases of dementia, and 32,000 cases of diabetes);

  • Savings of €578 million per year in healthcare spending;

  • An increase in employment and productivity equivalent to an additional 19,800 full-time equivalents (FTEs) per year.

The cost of the measures evaluated—estimated at around €148 million per year—would be offset by savings on healthcare spending in the long term, with an average return of €4 for every euro invested.

Ninth Annual No Tobacco Month

While the ninth annual “No Tobacco Month”—a public challenge inviting smokers to quit smoking for 30 consecutive days—was in full swing, the BEH published an assessment of the health and economic impact of this social marketing campaign carried out by Santé publique France and the OECD; this assessment shows a largely favorable return on investment, with approximately €7 saved in healthcare expenditures for every euro invested. The detailed results of this assessment are available on the Santé publique France website.

This national event, established by the French Ministry of Health and Access to Healthcare and Santé publique France, in partnership with the French Health Insurance Fund, has been held every year since its inception in 2016.

Its goal is to encourage smokers to quit as part of a collective effort, with the support of those around them. Each year, resources are available to help them, including the Tabac Info Service website and a dedicated hotline, 39 89, which offers free access to consultations with a tobacco dependence specialist. Nearly 6 out of 10 smokers want to quit: preparing them and providing support means giving them every opportunity to rise to the challenge of a tobacco-free life.