Evaluation of a media campaign aimed at raising awareness of the long-term harms of alcohol and guidelines for low-risk drinking, and at reducing alcohol consumption.
Effectiveness of a French mass media campaign in raising awareness of both long-term alcohol-related harms and guidelines for low-risk drinking, and in reducing alcohol consumption.
See also
View all articles from this month, sorted by year
Alcohol consumption is a major risk factor for premature death and chronic diseases. This impact is observed even at low levels of alcohol consumption. Several countries, including France in 2017, have established alcohol consumption limits to reduce health risks (see Box).
That same year, the Santé publique France Health Barometer—a national survey conducted among a representative sample of the French population—showed that nearly a quarter of people aged 18–75 consumed alcohol in excess of these recommendations.¹
It was in this context that Santé publique France launched the “Ravages” campaign in 2019, a national awareness campaign on the health effects of alcohol and new consumption guidelines. A TV spot, radio segments featuring experts, digital banners, and posters were released as part of this multimedia campaign. The goal: to reduce alcohol consumption in France.
While some studies, including experimental ones, tend to show that mass media campaigns change public knowledge and attitudes in a way that leads to reduced alcohol consumption, do these results hold true in the real-world context of a campaign targeting the general population?
This question is addressed in an article recently published in the international journal Addiction. It presents the results of the evaluation of the 2019 Ravages alcohol campaign and demonstrates how it provided useful insights for the implementation of future awareness campaigns.
3 questions for Guillemette Quatremère, Directorate of Prevention and Health Promotion, Santé publique France
The “Ravages” prevention campaign, which addresses the risks of alcohol, was developed and launched following an expert report on public discourse regarding alcohol, published in 2017 (see box). This expert group had, in fact, issued several recommendations, including the importance of informing the public that the health risks associated with alcohol consumption increase with the amount consumed, emphasizing that there is no such thing as alcohol consumption without health risks, and that there are guidelines for lower-risk consumption. The 2019 campaign was the first by Santé publique France to address the long-term risks associated with alcohol and to publicize these guidelines for lower-risk consumption.
It thus had two main objectives:
To improve the public’s understanding of the medium- and long-term risks associated with alcohol consumption. Three conditions were highlighted in the campaign: cancer, hypertension, and cerebral hemorrhage.
To raise awareness of the new guidelines for lower-risk drinking, summarized as “alcohol is a maximum of 2 drinks per day, and not every day.”
Ultimately, the goal was to reduce the proportion of drinkers exceeding these guidelines in order to eventually lower alcohol-attributable morbidity and mortality.
The first rollout of the campaign in March–April 2019 was evaluated using a longitudinal follow-up of 4,002 drinkers (a sample selected using the quota method). They were surveyed online before the campaign (February 22–March 18), immediately after (April 17–May 12), and approximately six months later (September 25–October 15): 2,538 people responded to all three survey waves.
The main indicators of the evaluation were: awareness of the risks highlighted in the campaign (cancer, hypertension, cerebral hemorrhage), awareness of the guidelines, and self-reported alcohol consumption relative to the guidelines.
Following the campaign’s launch, among drinkers—including those who exceed the guidelines and therefore pose a greater risk to their health—a link was observed between exposure to the campaign and greater awareness of the “maximum 2 drinks per day” guideline, as well as greater knowledge of the risks of hypertension and cerebral hemorrhage. Another positive finding: there is an association between exposure to the campaign and a decrease in the proportion of at-risk drinkers across the entire sample. However, no association was observed between exposure to the campaign and awareness of the link between alcohol and cancer, or awareness of the guideline regarding the number of days without alcohol consumption.
More detailed analyses reveal differences based on respondent profiles: the link between exposure to the campaign and a decrease in the proportion of at-risk drinkers is driven by women, and the link with improved perception of the risk of alcohol consumption on high blood pressure is observed only among higher socioeconomic groups.
These positive results, however, diminish over time: the favorable effects observed are no longer significant after six months.
These findings contribute to the scientific literature showing that alcohol-related campaigns disseminated through mass media can be effective in improving public knowledge about alcohol and changing attitudes toward it.² Evidence regarding the effect on reducing alcohol consumption is, however, more limited³. Nevertheless, recent experimental studies have shown a potential impact on drinking behaviors from campaigns combining messages about long-term risks and consumption benchmarks. The strength of our study lies in demonstrating that, under “real-life” conditions, a social marketing campaign on alcohol can have effects on knowledge and behavior.
The fact that the campaign’s effects are no longer noticeable after a few months is consistent with the scientific literature (including for campaigns on topics other than alcohol) and supports the case for repeated rollouts of large-scale campaigns. The 2019 campaign was thus successively improved (creation of new visuals and more educational messages on risks and guidelines, adaptation of the media plan to ensure good visibility among target audiences) and rebroadcast six times over four years.
Today, our studies show that alcohol still enjoys a largely positive image among the general public, that guidelines for lower-risk consumption are still insufficiently known, and that the risks associated with even small amounts of alcohol are either misunderstood or dismissed as irrelevant to one’s own drinking habits. It therefore appears necessary to continue to demystify alcohol and remind people that it is a product that poses health risks, even in small doses. Changing perceptions takes time… and changing behaviors even more so.
To prevent the public from becoming desensitized to the Ravages campaign, we are developing new communication strategies. The campaign “Good health has nothing to do with alcohol,” launched in January 2023, highlights the long-term risks of alcohol and invites us to reflect on its place in our lives, pointing out a cultural absurdity that affects us all: the act of toasting and wishing each other “health / good health”… with alcohol.
January, a time for New Year’s resolutions, is an ideal moment to reflect on our drinking habits: hence the “Dry January” challenge, launched in France in 2020 by a coalition of organizations, based on a model that originated in the United Kingdom. It is a one-month alcohol-free challenge designed to examine one’s relationship with alcohol and observe the benefits to one’s quality of life. The evaluation conducted by the agency in 2020 revealed the value of this initiative in helping people step back and reduce their alcohol consumption.
To receive support in this process of reflection or reduction in consumption, the alcohol-info-service website (see box) offers advice and assistance if needed, and features a digital tool called the “alcoometer” that allows users to assess their consumption against benchmarks and understand the health risks involved.
Beyond social marketing aimed at the general public and the remote support tools offered by Alcool-info-service, Santé publique France is conducting other work on the topic of alcohol prevention: rollout of initiatives targeting specific audiences, such as young people, with the aim of reinforcing protective behaviors in party settings (Amis aussi la nuit), evaluation and dissemination of various interventions to strengthen psychosocial skills among adolescents, and advocacy for regulatory measures that create an environment conducive to reducing consumption (for example, by limiting advertising for alcoholic beverages). It is the combination of these efforts that can ultimately create an environment conducive to changing the image of alcoholic beverages and lead to a decline in alcohol consumption in France.
[1] Quatremère G., Guignard R., Cogordan C., Andler R., Gallopel-Morvan K., Nguyen-Thanh V. Effectiveness of a French mass-media campaign in raising awareness of both long-term alcohol-related harms and low-risk drinking guidelines, and in reducing alcohol consumption. Addiction. 2022. https://doi.org/10.1111/add.16107
Experts Examine Guidelines for Lower-Risk Alcohol Consumption
A group of independent experts (epidemiologists, addiction specialists, and health education specialists) was commissioned in 2017 by Santé publique France and the National Cancer Institute to shift the public discourse on alcohol consumption in France. One of their tasks was to develop guidelines for lower-risk consumption, based on scientific literature, modeling studies, and a qualitative study.
The modeling was entrusted to two Canadian researchers from the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (Toronto). The risk of alcohol-attributable mortality for the French population was modeled according to different alcohol exposure scenarios (ranging from 0 g to 100 g of pure alcohol per day), confirming that there is no such thing as risk-free alcohol consumption. Next, they compared these risk levels and the associated consumption levels with the perceptions and attitudes of the French population, as part of a qualitative study. The study confirmed that “zero alcohol” was not an achievable goal and that benchmarks acceptable to the population needed to be established. This approach is rooted in a risk-reduction perspective.
The qualitative study demonstrated the need for a dual consumption framework—daily and weekly—without distinction by gender. This was feasible because, at the selected consumption threshold, health risks differ little between men and women.
The new low-risk consumption guidelines thus have three components and are intended for healthy adults: “If you drink alcohol, to limit health risks over the course of your life, it is recommended that you: consume no more than 10 standard drinks per week and no more than 2 standard drinks per day; and have days during the week when you do not drink at all.”
These guidelines have been rephrased to make them easier for the general public to remember and understand as: “for your health, limit alcohol to a maximum of 2 drinks per day, and not every day.”
Learn more about the report: Expert opinion on the evolution of public discourse regarding alcohol consumption in France, organized by Santé publique France and the National Cancer Institute.
What is Alcool Info Service? Advice for Everyone
Alcool Info Service is a national resource providing information, guidance, and personalized support, accessible to everyone online at www.alcool-info-service.fr or by phone at 0 980 980 930, available 7 days a week from 8 a.m. to 2 a.m.
The Alcool-info-service.fr website provides the general public with a wealth of information, advice on reducing alcohol consumption, and tools such as the alcohol meter, which helps assess the risks of alcohol consumption.
The site also helps foster open dialogue by encouraging interaction and mutual support through interactive features (the Q&A service, forums, the testimonials section, etc.) and individual chats (a space for real-time dialogue between the user and a professional).
In addition, the Alcool Info Service website lists all specialized addiction treatment facilities in a national directory of over 3,000 facilities.
Learn more:
Alcohol consumption guidelines
Andler R, Richard JB, Cogordan C, Deschamps V, Escalon H, Nguyen-Thanh V, et al. New alcohol consumption and use guidelines: results from the 2017 Public Health France Barometer. Bull Epidémiol Hebd. 2019;(10-11):180-7.
Andler R, Quatremère G, Gautier A, Soullier N, Lahaie E, Richard J-B, et al. Exceeding low-risk alcohol consumption guidelines in 2020: results from the Santé publique France Health Barometer. Bull Epidemiol Hebd. 2021(17):304-12.
Alcohol consumption monitoring indicators and prevention measures
Evaluations of social marketing initiatives
Friends at Night Too: Ilaria Montagni, Maëlys Abraham, Christophe Tzourio, Amandine Luquiens, Viêt Nguyen-Thanh & Guillemette Quatremere (2022) Mixed-methods evaluation of a prevention campaign on binge drinking and cannabis use addressed to young people, Journal of Substance Use, DOI: 10.1080/14659891.2021.2022223
Alcohol consumption: evaluation of the first edition of the January Challenge—Dry January in France in 2020 (Santé publique France)
Programs to strengthen psychosocial skills
Psychosocial skills: state of scientific and theoretical knowledge. Saint-Maurice: Santé publique France, 2022. 135 p.
Addictions: prevention and consumption behaviors. du Roscoät E, Spilka S, Lecrique J-M, Gillaizeau I, Quatremère G, Nguyen-Thanh V, et al. La Santé en action. 2019(449):11-3.
Unplugged Program: https://www.santepubliquefrance.fr/docs/resultats-de-l-evaluation-du-programme-unplugged-dans-le-loiret
Gillaizeau I. Evaluation of a program to prevent psychoactive substance use among young construction apprentices.
Advocacy for Regulatory Measures
Gallopel-Morvan K, Andler R, Nguyen Thanh V, Critchlow N. Does the French Évin Law on Alcohol Advertising Content Reduce the Attractiveness of Alcohol for Young People? An Online Experimental Survey. J Stud Alcohol Drugs. 2022;83(2):276-86.
Quatremère G, Guignard R, Andler R, Avenel J, Gallopel-Morvan K, Nguyen-Thanh V, To what extent are the French exposed to alcohol advertising? An evaluation of advertising investments made between 2018 and 2020. SFA Conference, March 24–25, 2022, Lyon.
1- Andler R, Quatremère G, Gautier A, Soullier N, Lahaie E, Richard J-B, et al. Exceeding the guidelines for low-risk alcohol consumption in 2020: results from the Santé publique France Health Barometer. Bull Epidemiol Hebd. 2021(17):304-12.
2- Wakefield MA, Loken B, Hornik RC. Use of mass media campaigns to change health behavior. Lancet. 2010;376(9748):1261-71
3- Young B, Lewis S, Katikireddi SV, Bauld L, Stead M, Angus K, et al. Effectiveness of Mass Media Campaigns to Reduce Alcohol Consumption and Harm: A Systematic Review. Alcohol Alcohol. 2018;53(3):302-16