thematic dossier
2024 Olympic and Paralympic Games
Here you will find all the information on Santé publique France’s efforts in connection with the 2024 Olympic Games, the resources made available to healthcare professionals, and national and...
Epidemiological surveillance and infectious disease outbreaks during large-scale international summer sports events: A narrative review
thematic dossier
Here you will find all the information on Santé publique France’s efforts in connection with the 2024 Olympic Games, the resources made available to healthcare professionals, and national and...
Hosting large numbers of spectators from around the world at major events—whether sporting, cultural, or religious—exacerbates the operational and scientific challenges faced by stakeholders responsible for monitoring and responding to epidemic risks. Increased crowd density and overcrowding on public transportation are just a few of the situations that must be managed.
In the case of the Paris 2024 Olympic and Paralympic Games (P2024), currently underway, more than 4 million spectators are expected, with high activity in Paris and more broadly in the Île-de-France (IDF) region, which is hosting the vast majority of events, participants, and spectators. The other events are spread across six other regions [Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur (PACA), Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes (ARA), Hauts-de-France (HdF), Pays de la Loire (PdL), Nouvelle-Aquitaine (NA), and Centre-Val de Loire (CVL)]. The Île-de-France region will host all the sporting events of the Paralympic Games, with the exception of the shooting competition, which will take place in Centre-Val de Loire.
A recent article published in the journal Infectious Disease Now analyzes, through a narrative review of the literature, the infectious risks that have arisen during major sporting events held around the world over the past 30 years. The objective was to anticipate and prepare for surveillance measures to be implemented or strengthened in anticipation of the 2024 Paralympic Games in order to detect and assist in managing outbreaks should they occur during this period. The results of the review contribute to the rationale underlying the choice of the enhanced surveillance system implemented by Santé publique France for this occasion (see box – Enhanced Surveillance During the 2024 Olympic Games).
This study on large gatherings was initiated in 2021 by the Santé publique France team in Île-de-France and focused on all the risks associated with large gatherings of any kind. This literature review was shared with partners and health authorities in early 2022 to support risk mapping in preparation for the Paris 2024 Olympic and Paralympic Games. It was updated in 2023 in cooperation with the Infectious Diseases Directorate of Santé publique France to focus on infectious risks during major summer sporting events. The goal was to better identify the challenges posed by the 2024 Olympic Games.
This comprehensive review confirms that cases of infectious diseases are, of course, reported during major summer sporting events. Why wouldn’t they be, since they occur every summer even in the absence of such gatherings: outbreaks of foodborne illnesses, viral infections, Legionnaires’ disease, meningitis, and now* a few locally acquired cases of arboviral diseases (dengue, Chikungunya). However, this review also confirms that no epidemic that was already established prior to these events occurred. This was notably the case for Zika during the 2016 Olympic and Paralympic Games in Rio, meningitis and measles during the 2010 FIFA World Cup in South Africa, and COVID-19 during the UEFA European Championship in the United Kingdom and Italy in 2020. In summary, cases do occur during major summer sporting events, but they do not pose a significant additional public health risk to athletes, spectators, or the general population. This is especially true in cities, such as Paris, which welcome millions of tourists each year.
The published review focused solely on infectious risks capable of causing epidemics. Important point: spectators are present in stadiums and within the Games’ perimeter for relatively short periods of time—shorter, in particular, than the incubation periods of most pathogens. These participants therefore do not have time to contribute significantly to the spread of pathogens or to the risk of an epidemic in a given area and time frame. It is therefore advisable to prepare for the usual summer infectious risks mentioned above, even though the increased number of visitors may pose challenges in terms of management by the Regional Health Agencies (ARS) and interpretation of indicators by Santé publique France. Hence the importance of documenting as precisely as possible the number of people present in real time at a given location and site. Telephone data, for example, which is already used in France for modeling purposes, could be collected for this purpose. Having access to this detailed data will then provide a more accurate estimate of the number of people present (so-called population denominators) when evaluating data or risks.
Other health risks worth mentioning, identified during the initial 2021 review (unpublished), include those observed during heat peaks or prolonged heat episodes, and especially during heat waves. This was observed during the 1996 Atlanta Olympics and the 2021 Tokyo Olympics. These phenomena, which are becoming increasingly frequent in summer even in our latitudes, can have a rapid and massive impact on athletes, participants, and the general population.
It should be noted that the Heat Wave and Health Alert System (SACS), established in France after the summer of 2023 across the entire metropolitan territory and coordinated by Santé publique France in collaboration with Météo-France, is activated between June 1 and September 30. Its objective is to measure the health impact of heat on the population and to provide decision-making support to authorities.
Santé publique France has many years of experience managing large gatherings (Turin 2006, the 2014 D-Day celebrations, COP21 in 2015 in the Île-de-France region, the Grande Armada in 2023, etc.). This experience will continue to grow and must be guided by epidemiological imperatives. Together with all our colleagues at Santé publique France, we were able to conduct a trial run during the 2023 Rugby World Cup and test certain indicators** during the Grande Armada in Rouen.
The key lesson from monitoring these recent large gatherings—which requires significant mobilization of teams—is the importance of anticipating staffing needs. Indeed, this mobilization is in addition to the specific mobilization required for each individual’s other agency assignments.
France has many professionals involved in health surveillance, whether through dedicated surveillance efforts or routine surveillance, such as the Sursaud® syndromic surveillance system, mandatory disease reporting (DO), or reports of unusual health signals. The Paris 2024 Olympic Games provided an opportunity to implement new surveillance systems, such as the use of data from the Paris Fire Brigade (BSPP) or first-aid organizations around the stadiums, in connection with Paris 2024. Surveillance (via the BSPP) enables the collection of reasons for assistance requests and the number of victims treated (in Paris and departments 92, 93, and 94). Data from these surveillance efforts are published weekly throughout the 2024 Olympic Games in the Île-de-France 2024 Olympic Games bulletin. The performance of these new systems must still be evaluated before deciding whether or not to continue using them. Santé publique France, which coordinates the wastewater microbiological surveillance system (SUM’EAU), recently conducted a study aimed at identifying pathogens of interest for surveillance in wastewater in preparation for the 2024 Olympic Games. (See Box – The Value of Wastewater Surveillance During Large Gatherings).
The other lesson from public health surveillance during large gatherings is the inevitable occurrence of a small number of cases that do not pose a public health burden but are nonetheless reported. Regardless of the context, these cases must be investigated and either ruled out or confirmed to determine whether a health risk exists, a process that takes some time.
* First case in the Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur region in 2010 and in the Île-de-France region in 2023
**Trauma, Breathing difficulties, Muscle/joint pain and fever, Vomiting and/or diarrhea, Chest pain, Alcohol or drug use, Headache and fever, General symptoms (malaise, dizziness, fainting), Heat-related disorders, Eye irritation/redness, Skin rash, Drowning/fall into a river, Other
Santé publique France has implemented an enhanced surveillance system throughout the 2024 Olympic Games period, in collaboration with its partners. It builds on existing surveillance systems, which will be strengthened to address the challenges associated with this type of event. Surveillance will cover all populations present in mainland France from July 8 to September 15, 2024.
The SurSaUD® syndromic surveillance system (data from emergency room visits in the OSCOUR® network, SOS Médecins associations, all-cause mortality, and electronic death certificates)
The surveillance system for notifiable diseases (MDO)
Microbiological surveillance systems in collaboration with the National Reference Centers (CNR)
Surveillance systems based on networks of volunteer laboratories, physicians, and hospital departments
Other existing surveillance systems will be strengthened, such as surveillance of drowning, arboviruses, and air pollution.
In addition, new surveillance systems have been established:
an international surveillance system for infectious disease signals with support from the ECDC;
surveillance conducted in partnership with the Paris Fire Brigade, the SAMU, and emergency response teams.
Data from this enhanced surveillance is published weekly in the national JOP 2024 Weekly Bulletin and the regional JOP 2024 Bulletins.
Wastewater surveillance is a useful approach for monitoring public health, as demonstrated by the national SUM’Eau program (microbiological wastewater surveillance) launched in France in 2022 following the COVID-19 pandemic.
The study published this month in the journal Eurosurveillance and conducted in collaboration with the INSPQ (Quebec) and ANSES describes a model that identified targets for wastewater surveillance in the context of the large-scale gathering for the 2024 Olympic Games.
The identification of pathogens of interest for wastewater surveillance was based on a list of 60 pathogens that could pose a public health risk during the 2024 Olympic Games. Each pathogen was then evaluated based on three inclusion criteria: (A) the analytical feasibility of measuring it in wastewater; (B) the relevance of monitoring the pathogen given the specific nature of the event and the pathogen’s characteristics; and (C) the added value in informing public health decision-making.
Analytical feasibility (A) was assessed based on publications demonstrating the detectability of pathogens in wastewater, which narrowed the initial list down to 25 pathogens. Criteria B and C were then evaluated using expert opinions via the Delphi method*. The panel, composed of approximately thirty experts, proposed five additional pathogens meeting criterion A, for a total of 30 pathogens evaluated throughout the three rounds of the iterative questionnaire. A threshold of 70% consensus among experts was defined a priori to determine the inclusion of pathogens.
This analysis identified six priority targets suitable for wastewater surveillance during the Games: poliovirus, influenza A virus, influenza B virus, Monkeypox virus, SARS-CoV-2, and measles virus.
These targets hold potential for wastewater surveillance during future large gatherings.
* The Delphi method is a group facilitation technique designed to reach consensus by gathering expert opinions on a given topic through a series of anonymous, structured questionnaires.
Learn more:
Selected publications related to public health surveillance during large gatherings:
(1) Atiki N, Courtillet V, Joly LM, Dujardin A, Martel M. “Large gathering” surveillance during the 2023 Armada de Rouen. Weekly Epidemiological Bulletin. 2024;(10):214-20.
(2) Chanzy E, Gentile M, Nahon M, Paty AC, Stibbe O, Tourtier JP, Petrovic T, Goix L, Adnet F, Lapostolle F. COP21 – Organization and assessment of medical services under high pressure. Journal of Epidemiology and Public Health, 2019, vol. 67, no. 3, pp. 201-204.
(3) Franke F, Coulon L, Renaudat C, Euillot B, Kessalis N, Malfait P. The epidemiological surveillance system implemented in the Hautes-Alpes department during the 2006 Winter Olympics in Turin. Euro Surveill. 2006;11(12):pii=671.
Heat Waves & Health: Morbidity and Mortality Data from the Summer of 2023